Tom Cruise and Michael B Jordan are gracing the covers of prominent magazines this week, showcasing distinct representations of masculinity. These contrasting images appear amid ongoing debates over the nature of manhood, which have become a focal point in contemporary discourse around masculinity.
Cruise and Jordan: Different Takes on Masculine Imagery
At 64, Tom Cruise returns to the cover of GQ for the first time in two decades. Posing with an open shirt and a hand through his hair, the iconic action star strikes a classic pose intended to project sex appeal. However, this attempt has been met with criticism, as social media users, notably on GQ’s Instagram, have expressed collective disapproval of the imagery, branding it as out-of-touch or “unsexy.”
In contrast, 39-year-old Michael B Jordan appears on the cover of Vogue, marking a milestone as only the sixth man to appear solo in such a feature. Jordan is depicted reclining on a floral backdrop, his unbuttoned blazer revealing his toned physique. Comments have largely celebrated the image, with many expressing admiration and light-hearted envy.
Masculinity Under the Microscope
These covers arrive during a period where discussions around what defines masculinity are prevalent. The generational divide is evident with Cruise representing the boomer demographic and Jordan emblematic of millennials. The varied portrayals highlight shifts in perceptions of masculine identity.
Dr Ashley Morgan of Cardiff Metropolitan University points out that while there are multiple expressions of masculinity, societal focus often centres on the traditional male patriarch, exemplified by Cruise’s image. Jordan’s cover, according to Morgan, presents a broader, more inclusive representation, combining elements of Black masculinity with style.
Cultural and Fashion Perspectives
According to Andrew Groves, director of the menswear archive at the University of Westminster, Cruise’s fashion choice—a worn shirt and jeans—draws from traditional, rugged masculinity. Conversely, Jordan’s look, adorned with fashion elements and jewellery, showcases a softer, more decorative approach to masculinity.
Alona Pardo, who curated an exhibition on masculinity, and Jessa Crispin, author of What’s Wrong with Men, argue that both covers adhere to norms that reinforce virility and male dominance. These portrayals serve as a response against societal movements like #MeToo, suggesting a reclamation of traditional masculine values.
GQ’s editorial direction reflects an ongoing evolution in how masculinity is depicted. Under Adam Baidawi, the magazine aims to be a definitive guide to masculine identity, a mission echoed in past issues featuring varied expressions of manhood, such as Pharrell Williams’ gown-like coat and Jeremy Strong’s practical attire.
Reporting based on coverage first published by theguardian.com.